9 Different Types of Game Testing Techniques

In the dynamic and ever-evolving realm of game development, game testing stands as a cornerstone of success. The recent tribulations faced by industry giants due to bug-ridden releases have brought the necessity of rigorous testing into stark focus.

As the global gaming industry is poised to reach a staggering US$363.20bn by 2027, the significance of testing cannot be overstated.

#1) Combinatorial Testing:

Combinatorial testing is a software testing technique that focuses on testing all possible combinations of input values for a given feature or function. This approach is particularly useful for game testing, as it can help to identify bugs or issues that may only occur under specific combinations of circumstances.

Benefits of Combinatorial Testing in Game Testing:

1. Efficient Test Case Generation: Reduces the number of manual test cases required by systematically identifying and testing all relevant combinations of input values.

2. Thorough Coverage: Ensures that all possible interactions between different game elements are tested, maximizing the likelihood of uncovering hidden bugs or issues.

3. Reduced Test Effort: Streamlines the testing process by eliminating the need to create and execute a large number of test cases manually.

4. Improved Bug Detection: It finds bugs that conventional testing techniques might not catch, resulting in a higher-quality game.

Application of Combinatorial Testing in Games:

1. Gameplay Mechanics: Testing various combinations of character attributes, item interactions, and environmental factors to ensure consistent and balanced gameplay.

2. Configuration Settings: Verifying the behavior of the game under different graphics settings, difficulty levels, and language options.

3. Player Choice and Progression: Testing the impact of player choices and actions on game progression, ensuring that all paths lead to a satisfying and bug-free experience.

Challenges of Combinatorial Testing in Games:

1. Complexity of Game Systems: As game systems become more complex, the number of possible input combinations increases exponentially, making it challenging to test all combinations exhaustively.

2. Identification of Relevant Input Parameters: Determining which input values are most likely to affect the game’s behavior and focusing testing efforts on those parameters.

3. Prioritization of Test Cases: Prioritizing test cases based on their risk and potential impact ensures that critical combinations are tested first.

4. Utilization of Testing Tools: Employing specialized combinatorial testing tools to automate the test case generation process and manage the large number of test cases.

#2) Clean Room Testing:

Clean Room Testing in Game Development

Cleanroom testing is a software development methodology that emphasizes defect prevention rather than defect detection. In the context of game testing, cleanroom testing involves a structured process of creating test cases based on formal specifications, ensuring that the game is thoroughly tested before it reaches the player.

Key Principles of Cleanroom Testing in Game Testing:

1. Incremental Development: The game is developed and tested in small increments, allowing for early identification and correction of defects.

2. Formal Specifications: Clear and detailed specifications are created to define the game’s expected behavior and provide a basis for test case generation.

3. Static Analysis: Thorough review of the game’s code and design to identify potential defects before they manifest during testing.

4. Functional Testing: Systematic testing of the game’s features and functionality to ensure they meet the specified requirements.

5. Dynamic Testing: Testing of the game in a running state to uncover runtime defects and ensure overall stability and performance.

Benefits of Cleanroom Testing in Game Testing:

1. Reduced Defect Rates: A proactive defect prevention approach leads to fewer bugs and errors in the final game.

2. Improved Game Quality: An emphasis on quality throughout the development process results in a higher-quality and more polished game.

3. Lower Development Costs: Early detection and correction of defects reduce the need for costly rework and delays.

4. Enhanced Customer Satisfaction: Delivery of a high-quality game with minimal bugs leads to satisfied customers and positive reviews.

5. Stronger Brand Reputation: Consistent production of high-quality games strengthens brand reputation and customer trust.

Challenges of Cleanroom Testing in Game Testing:

1. Initial Investment: Implementing cleanroom testing requires an initial investment in training, tools, and processes.

2. Formal Specification Overhead: Creating detailed formal specifications can be time-consuming and may require specialized expertise.

3. Maintenance of Specifications: As the game evolves,

#3) Functionality Testing:

Functional testing in game development is a crucial process that ensures the game functions as intended and meets the player’s expectations. It involves testing the game’s core features, mechanics, and gameplay to identify and fix any bugs or issues that could hinder the player’s experience.

Objectives of Functional Testing in Games:

1. Verify Game Functionality: Ensure that game features, mechanics, and gameplay elements work as intended and meet design specifications.

2. Identify and Resolve Bugs: Detect and fix bugs that cause crashes, freezes, progression blockers, or other disruptions to gameplay.

3. Validate User Experience: Evaluate the overall user experience, ensuring that the game is intuitive, engaging, and enjoyable to play.

4. Ensure Compliance with Requirements: Verify that the game adheres to all technical and functional requirements outlined in design documents and specifications.

Techniques for Functional Testing in Games:

1. Black-box Testing: Testing the game without prior knowledge of its internal structure or code, focusing on user interactions and observable behavior.

2. White-box Testing: Testing the game with an understanding of its internal code and structure, enabling more in-depth testing of specific functions and modules.

3. Exploratory Testing: Testing the game in an unstructured and open-ended manner, allowing testers to uncover unexpected bugs and usability issues.

4. Regression Testing: Re-testing previously tested features and functionalities after changes to ensure that new bugs haven’t been introduced.

5. Play Testing: Involving actual players to test the game in a real-world setting, providing valuable feedback on gameplay, balance, and overall experience.

Benefits of Functional Testing in Games:

1. Improved Game Quality: Identifies and fixes bugs early in the development process, preventing them from reaching players and causing frustration.

2. Enhanced User Experience: Ensures that the game is intuitive, engaging, and enjoyable to play, leading to satisfied customers and positive reviews.

3. Reduced Development Costs: Prevents costly rework and delays caused by late-stage bug discovery, saving time and resources.

4. Increased Customer Satisfaction: Delivers a high-quality game that meets player expectations, leading to positive word-of-mouth and customer loyalty.

5. Stronger Business Reputation: Establishes a reputation for delivering reliable and bug-free games, enhancing brand reputation and customer trust.

Also Read  : Game Testing Tutorial: All you need to know to be a game tester

#4) Compatibility Testing:

In game development, compatibility testing plays a crucial role in ensuring that the game runs smoothly and seamlessly across a wide range of hardware configurations, software environments, and input devices. It aims to identify and resolve any compatibility issues that could hinder the player’s experience.

Objectives of Compatibility Testing in Games:

1. Hardware Compatibility: Verify that the game runs effectively on various hardware configurations, including different processors, graphics cards, and memory capacities.

2. Software Compatibility: Ensure that the game functions correctly under different operating systems, browsers, and third-party software applications.

3. Input Device Compatibility: Validate the game’s compatibility with various input devices, such as keyboards, mice, gamepads, and touchscreens.

4. Cross-Platform Compatibility: Test the game’s performance and functionality across multiple platforms, such as PCs, consoles, and mobile devices.

5. Localization Compatibility: Verify the game’s compatibility with different languages, ensuring proper text translation, audio localization, and cultural adaptations.

Techniques for Compatibility Testing in Games:

1. Manual Testing: Hand-testing the game on a variety of hardware and software configurations to identify compatibility issues.

2. Automated Testing: Utilizing automated testing tools to perform repetitive compatibility tests across different environments.

3. Emulation Testing: Using emulation software to simulate specific hardware and software environments for testing.

4. Cloud-Based Testing: Leveraging cloud-based testing platforms to access a wide range of hardware and software configurations for testing.

5. User Feedback: Gathering feedback from users playing the game on various devices and systems to identify compatibility issues

Benefits of Compatibility Testing in Games:

1. Enhanced User Experience: Ensure a consistent and enjoyable gaming experience for players using different hardware and software setups.

2. Reduced Customer Support Burden: Minimize the number of compatibility-related support requests from players.

3. Improved Brand Reputation: Build a reputation for delivering games that work seamlessly across a wide range of devices.

4. Expanded Market Reach: Enable the game to reach a broader audience, including those with diverse hardware and software preferences.

5. Increased Sales and Revenue: Potentially increase sales and revenue by catering to a wider range of players.

Challenges of Compatibility Testing in Games:

1. Complexity of Modern Hardware and Software: The ever-increasing diversity of hardware and software configurations makes it challenging to test for all possible combinations.

2. Resource Requirements: Compatibility testing can be resource-intensive, requiring access to various hardware and software configurations, testing tools, and skilled testers.

3. Keeping Up with Rapid Changes: The rapid pace of technological advancements necessitates continuous testing to ensure compatibility with new hardware, software, and input devices.

4. Balancing Compatibility with Performance: Ensuring compatibility across a wide range of devices may require optimization to maintain performance on lower-end hardware.

5. Addressing Regional and Cultural Differences: Localization testing can be complex, requiring consideration of regional differences in language, culture, and regulatory requirements.

Strategies for Effective Compatibility Testing:

1. Prioritize Target Platforms: Identify the most relevant hardware and software configurations based on the target audience and market demographics.

2. Utilize Automation and Tools: Employ automated testing tools and cloud-based testing platforms to streamline the testing process and reduce manual effort.

3. Embrace Continuous Testing: Integrate compatibility testing into the development process, performing tests throughout the development cycle and after updates.

4. Gather User Feedback: Encourage user feedback through beta testing programs and community forums to identify compatibility issues in real-world scenarios.

5. Maintain Compatibility Documentation: Document compatibility test results and identify issues to facilitate future testing and troubleshooting.

#5) Tree Testing:

Tree testing is a usability testing technique commonly used in game development to evaluate the information architecture of a game’s menu system or navigation structure. It helps to determine how easily players can find the desired information or functionality within the game’s user interface.

The objective of Tree Testing in Game Testing:

1. Assess Navigation Clarity: Evaluate the intuitiveness and clarity of the game’s menu structure and navigation options.

2. Identify Label Effectiveness: Assess the effectiveness of menu labels and category headings in conveying their intended meaning and guiding players to the desired content.

3. Measure Task Completion Rates: Determine how successfully players can complete specific tasks, such as finding a specific item, accessing a particular setting, or unlocking a new feature.

4. Uncover Usability Issues: Uncover potential usability issues that might hinder players’ ability to navigate the game efficiently and effectively.

5. Optimize Menu Design: Gather insights to optimize the menu design and improve the overall user experience.

Methodology of Tree Testing in Game Testing:

1. Create a Hierarchical Tree: Represent the game’s menu structure as a hierarchical tree diagram, with each node representing a menu or submenu option.

2. Recruit Participants: Recruit a representative group of players to participate in the tree testing session.

3. Present Tasks: Present participants with a series of tasks, each requesting them to locate a specific item or functionality within the game’s menu structure.

4. Observe and Record: Observe participants as they navigate the menu, recording their interactions, comments, and any difficulties they encounter.

5. Analyze Results: Analyze the collected data to identify common patterns, usability issues, and areas for improvement.

Benefits of Tree Testing in Game Testing:

1. Early Identification of Usability Issues: Uncover usability issues early in the development process when they are easier and less costly to fix.

2. Iterative Design Improvement: Enable iterative refinement of the menu design based on user feedback and observed behaviors.

3. Enhanced User Experience: Contribute to a more intuitive and user-friendly game experience, reducing frustration and improving player satisfaction.

4. Reduced Development Costs: Prevent the need for costly rework later in the development cycle due to usability issues.

5. Improved Game Quality: Enhance the overall quality of the game by addressing usability concerns early on.

Challenges of Tree Testing in Game Testing:

1. Representing Complex Game Menus: Accurately representing complex game menus with multiple levels and branching paths can be challenging.

2. Participant Selection: Selecting a representative sample of players with diverse gaming experiences and backgrounds can be tricky.

3. Task Design: Crafting clear and concise tasks that accurately reflect real-world player actions can be challenging.

4. Managing Participant Expectations: Setting clear expectations and avoiding confusion with participants unfamiliar with tree testing

5. Interpreting Results: Interpreting qualitative and quantitative data from tree testing may require expertise in usability analysis.

• Improves the overall understanding of the complex features in the game

#6) Regression Testing:

Ad hoc testing is an informal software testing method that is often used in game development. It involves testing the game without a predefined plan or test cases, relying on the tester’s experience, intuition, and creativity to identify defects. Ad hoc testing can be performed at any stage of the development process, but it is most often used in the later stages when the game is more stable and there is less time to create and execute formal test cases.

Benefits of Ad hoc testing in game testing:

• Can identify defects that formal testing may miss.
• Can be performed quickly and easily.
• Does not require any documentation.
• Can be used to test the game in a variety of real-world scenarios.

Challenges of Ad hoc testing in game testing:

• Can be difficult to track and manage.
• Can be inconsistent in its results.
• Can be difficult to automate.
• Can be time-consuming if not performed carefully.

Here are some tips for performing ad hoc testing in game testing:

• Be familiar with the game and its features.
• Start by testing the most basic functionality of the game.
• Gradually explore more complex features and scenarios.
• Use a variety of input methods and devices.
• Pay attention to your instincts and follow up on any hunches you have.
• Record your findings and share them with the team.

Ad hoc testing can be a valuable tool for identifying defects in game development. However, it is important to use it in conjunction with other testing methods, such as formal testing and exploratory testing, to ensure that the game is thoroughly tested.

video game tester

Here are some examples of how ad hoc testing can be used in game testing:

• Testing the game’s controls to make sure they are responsive and intuitive.
• Testing the game’s menus to make sure they are easy to navigate.
• Testing the game’s levels to make sure they are free of bugs and glitches.
• Testing the game’s multiplayer mode to make sure it is stable and free of connection issues.
• Testing the game’s localization to make sure it is accurate and culturally sensitive.

Ad hoc testing can be a great way to find defects that might otherwise go unnoticed. However, it is important to remember that it is not a substitute for formal testing. It is important to use a variety of testing methods to ensure that the game is thoroughly tested and free of defects.

Must Read : 52 Software Testing Tools You Must Know in 2019

#8) Load Testing:

Load testing is a crucial aspect of game development, ensuring that the game can handle the anticipated number of concurrent users without experiencing performance degradation or stability issues. It involves simulating a large number of users interacting with the game simultaneously to assess its scalability and identify potential bottlenecks that could hinder the player experience.

Objectives of Load Testing in Game Testing:

1. Determine Maximum User Capacity: Identify the maximum number of players the game can support without performance deterioration.
2. Evaluate Server Scalability: Assess the game’s ability to scale up and down effectively in response to varying user traffic.
3. Uncover Performance Bottlenecks: Identify areas in the game’s infrastructure or code that may cause performance issues under load.
4. Prevent Crashes and Stability Problems: Ensure the game remains stable and crash-free even under heavy usage.
5. Optimize Resource Utilization: Analyze resource utilization patterns to identify areas for optimization and efficiency improvements.

Techniques for Load Testing in Game Testing:

1. Simulation Tools: Utilize specialized load-testing tools to simulate a large number of concurrent users and generate realistic user traffic.
2. Cloud-Based Testing: Leverage cloud-based testing platforms to access a vast pool of testing resources and simulate a wide range of user scenarios.
3. Performance Monitoring: Employ performance monitoring tools to track key metrics such as server response time, resource usage, and error rates.
4. Gradual Load Increase: Gradually increase the simulated user load to observe the game’s behavior and identify performance degradation points.
5. Real-World Scenarios: Replicate real-world usage patterns, such as peak player activity during game launches or popular events.

Benefits of Load Testing in Game Testing:

1. Proactive Defect Identification: Uncover performance issues and potential crashes early in the development process, reducing the cost of fixing them later.
2. Enhanced Scalability: Ensure the game can handle the anticipated user demand, preventing server overload and player frustration.
3. Improved Game Performance: Optimize the game’s performance under load, providing a smoother and more enjoyable player experience.
4. Reduced Server Costs: Identify and address performance bottlenecks, potentially reducing infrastructure costs associated with scaling up servers.
5. Enhanced Customer Satisfaction: Minimize downtime and performance issues, leading to happier players and positive word-of-mouth.

Challenges of Load Testing in Game Testing:

1. Complexity of Game Systems: Simulating the complex interactions and behaviors of a large number of players can be challenging and resource-intensive.
2. Variable User Behavior: Accurately replicating real-world user behavior patterns can be difficult, as players may exhibit diverse actions and preferences.
3. Resource Requirements: Load testing often requires access to substantial computing resources, which can be costly and time-consuming to procure.
4. Interpreting Results: Analyzing the vast amount of data generated during load testing requires expertise in performance analysis and optimization.
5. Integration with Agile Development: Adapting load testing to the iterative nature of agile development requires careful planning and coordination.

Strategies for Effective Load Testing in Game Testing:

1. Define Clear Testing Objectives: Clearly define the testing objectives, such as determining maximum user capacity or identifying specific performance bottlenecks.
2. Choose Appropriate Tools and Methods: Select the most suitable load-testing tools and methods based on the game’s architecture, complexity, and testing goals.
3. Create Realistic Scenarios: Develop realistic test scenarios that accurately reflect real-world player behavior and usage patterns.
4. Monitor Key Performance Metrics: Continuously monitor key performance metrics, such as response time, resource utilization, and error rates, to identify potential issues.
5. Analyze and Prioritize Results: Thoroughly analyze the collected data, prioritize identified issues based on their severity and impact, and develop a remediation plan.
6. Communicate Effectively: Communicate testing results to stakeholders, including developers, product managers, and executives, to inform decision-making and ensure timely resolution of critical issues.

#9) Play Testing:

Play testing is a critical aspect of game development, involving actual players interacting with the game in a real-world setting to provide valuable feedback and identify potential issues. It complements other testing methods, such as functional testing and performance testing, by providing insights into the overall user experience and gameplay.

Objectives of Play Testing in Game Testing:

1. Evaluate Gameplay Mechanics: Assess the effectiveness of the game’s core mechanics, ensuring they are engaging, balanced, and enjoyable for players.
2. Identify Usability Issues: Uncover usability issues that may hinder players’ ability to navigate the game, understand its rules, and achieve their goals.
3. Gather Feedback on Game Design: Collect player feedback on various aspects of game design, including character design, level design, storytelling, and overall aesthetic.
4. Detect Bugs and Glitches: Identify bugs, glitches, and other technical issues that may disrupt the gameplay or cause frustration for players.
5. Validate Game Balance: Assess the overall balance of the game, ensuring that different elements, such as characters, weapons, and difficulty levels, are appropriately balanced.

Types of Play Testing in Game Testing:

1. Alpha Testing: Conducted early in the development process, typically with a small group of internal testers or trusted players, to gather feedback on core gameplay mechanics and identify major bugs.
2. Beta Testing: Involves a larger group of players, often selected through invitations or registrations, to provide more comprehensive feedback on the game’s overall experience and identify potential issues.
3. Stress Testing: Focuses on simulating extreme conditions, such as a large influx of players or unexpected usage patterns, to assess the game’s scalability and stability under heavy load.
4. Localization Testing: Ensures that the game is properly localized for different languages and regions, considering cultural nuances, translation accuracy, and user interface adaptations.
5. Accessibility Testing: Evaluates the game’s accessibility for players with disabilities, ensuring that they can navigate the game, understand its mechanics, and participate fully in the gameplay.

Benefits of Play Testing in Game Testing:

1. Uncovers Real-World Issues: Identifies usability issues, bugs, and balance problems that may not be apparent through traditional testing methods.
2. Provides Player Perspective: Offers valuable insights into the game’s playability, engagement, and overall user experience from the player’s perspective.
3. Early Defect Detection: Detects bugs and issues early in the development process, reducing the cost of fixing them later.
4. Improved Game Quality: Leads to a more polished and enjoyable game that meets player expectations.
5. Enhanced Customer Satisfaction: Prevents frustrating experiences for players, contributing to positive word-of-mouth and customer satisfaction.

Challenges of Play Testing in Game Testing:

1. Managing Feedback: Effectively managing and analyzing a large volume of player feedback can be challenging.
2. Prioritizing Issues: Prioritizing identified issues based on their severity and impact on the overall gameplay experience requires careful consideration.
3. Balancing Feedback: Balancing feedback from different players with diverse preferences and gaming styles can be tricky.
4. Maintaining Transparency: Communicating play testing results and addressing player concerns effectively is crucial for maintaining transparency and trust.
5. Integrating with Agile Development: Adapting playtesting to the iterative nature of agile development requires flexibility and collaboration between testers and developers.

Strategies for Effective Play Testing in Game Testing:

1. Define Clear Goals and Objectives: Clearly define the goals and objectives of each play testing session, focusing on specific aspects of the game or gameplay elements.
2. Recruit a Diverse Group of Players: Select a diverse group of players with varied gaming experience, backgrounds, and skill levels to represent the target audience.
3. Provide Clear Instructions and Feedback Mechanisms: Provide clear instructions and establish effective feedback mechanisms to gather comprehensive and actionable feedback from players.
4. Observe and Monitor Player Behavior: Observe players’ interactions with the game, note their reactions, and monitor their progress to identify potential issues.
5. Analyze and Prioritize Feedback: Analyze the collected feedback, prioritize issues based on their impact, and communicate findings to developers for timely resolution.
6. Iterate and Improve: Continuously iterate on the game based on player feedback, refining the gameplay experience and addressing identified issues.

Conclusion

So what should the main focus of game testing be, should it be reality or vision? Nowadays, a game development team needs to spend more time on testing procedures than any other app development procedure as sometimes it becomes more complex due to the different components.

Even with better planning, an implementation may not necessarily work. And like any other app, users rely on charm only for some time and eventually want to have better results and a better user experience.

Recommended : 52 Software Tester Interview Questions That can Land You the Job